All One; All Different -- Addressing Spiritual Reductionism

"We're one, but we are not the same."-Bono, U2

Once I was in a train station waiting for a train with a friend. He pointed to a steel and cement column and said, "at the sub-atomic level, this column is mostly air. So are you. So am I?". And he went on to state we were the same as the column-no difference-and no different from one another. He went on to imply that there was, therefore, no meaning to anything. I stretched my arm out, made a fist, and pushed my fist at the column until it stopped with a thud. I looked at him and I said, "that may be so, AND at the same time, the world we move through is not the sub-atomic world".

Often we are addressed with reminders, assertions, and at times even pleas, that we are "all one". We are all human. We are all the same at some level. We all bleed red. At the sub-atomic level, we are all made up of the same stuff. In fact, at the sub-atomic level, at least at our current level of knowledge [see String Theory for an interesting hypothesis about how we may be very different from one another indeed], not only are we all "the same" as beings, we are the same as a rock, dirt, plant life, our dog, the wall, etc.

Eastern Spiritual traditions remind us that at the ultimate level, it is all vibrations, all wavelets. "Validated" by science, at the "ultimate" level, we are all the same-"just" sub-atomic particles.

And yet, anyone with eyes, ears, a tactile sense, and a mind can tell we are all very, very different. I challenge anyone who says that the ultimate level is the only important level ("we are all one") to Zen his or her way through me the next time we meet.

The problem with this is that most people cannot seem to contain both I.D.E.A.s intellectually, experientially, or spiritually, so then end up ignoring one or the other, or collapsing the informational and the practical. Does our having the same sub-atomic structures mean we are all the same?

Are you "the same" as a murderer? A rapist? A child molester? A terrorist? A priest? A politician? A man? A woman? A tribal leader? A shaman? A grocery clerk? A Fortune 500 CEO? Are you and I "the same" as Mozart, Bill Gates, Socrates, Thomas

Jefferson, or Ayn Rand? Of course not.

And, yes.

We have differing sets of skills, intelligence, symmetry, size, shape, and color. And yet...to paraphrase Ken Wilber, "while we are all perfect manifestations of the divine-of Spirit-yet how we demonstrate that is bound by our current level of development; we are limited to our current depth". Spiritual reductionism [we are all one and we are all perfect and we are all love] is usually accompanied by moral relativism. No act is inherently better than any other act. No world-view is more true than any other-and they are arbitrary.

I disagree.

Setting aside the performative contradiction (if no world-views are any more true than the other, then neither is that world-view-and thus it is false), compassion is better than anger because it possesses greater depth. Love is better than hate for the same reason. Grace is better than vengeance for the same reason-it requires an awareness of greater depth to exercise those choices, therefore, it is better.

Liberty is better than tyranny. Free Enterprise is better that centrally planned economies. In both cases they produce better results. Measurably better. Different beings possess different levels of awareness; different depths that that can reflect back by the development of their own depth. In this, we are very different indeed.

Is there utility in thinking we are all one-all the same? Perhaps. It can assist us in bridging potentially explosive differences in a world where differences in ideology can kill and maim. At the same time, in a world where ideologies can kill and maim, we had better keep the differences in mind as well.

In all things, be discerning, but not judgmental. Keep your mind open-but keep it working. Never allow someone to demand you turn off your common sense for their imagined utopia.

Jason McClain
IDEA
Evolutionary Guide
http://emotionalawareness.com

New York Times

A Focus on Light and Thrift New York Times, United States - 26 minutes ago Mr. Armstrong calls the style of the house, which cost him $20000 to build in 1988, “Zen rustic,” inspired by his longtime interest in Eastern spirituality. ...

Obama taps into our yearning for meaning, spirituality Detroit Free Press, United States - Nov 19, 2008 A survey out this month revealed that 52% of Americans age 12 to 25 say that they don't trust organized religion, but that they are increasingly spiritual. ...

Nature inspires a spiritual streak in us that usually doesn’t ... Cascadia Weekly, washington - Nov 19, 2008 Raised in a non-religious household, he didn’t realize he was developing a unique brand of spirituality that typifies our part of the world, ...

Oneindia

Spirituality Is An Intimate Experience Oneindia, India - Nov 19, 2008 Everything about spirituality is personal, intimate, and quiet. This is the exact opposite of how the outer world functions. My spiritual experience is more ...

Film festival on secularism, spirituality Galatta.com, India - 21 hours ago A package of films and documentaries that centre on secularism, family, relationships and spiritual quest will be screened. Half Moon, an award-winning ...

Religious diversity focus of conference at MSU Lansing State Journal, MI - Nov 19, 2008 On Thursday night, MSU jazz studies professor Rodney Whitaker will speak on “Spirituality & Jazz.” “For the university, it’s an opportunity to do research, ...

New book calls for "spirituality of place" in Pacific Northwest Vancouver Sun,  Canada - Nov 18, 2008 They maintain that while the residents of Cascadia are often not traditionally religious, many experience a spirituality based on the stunning natural ...

Survey: Most Youth Worldwide Spiritual, Say Religion is Good Christian Post - Nov 17, 2008 By Michelle A. Vu The majority of youths in the world say they are spiritual and think religion and spirituality are both positive, according to an ...

Mom Logic

Ignoring Prop. 8 backers' spirituality Mormon Times, UT - Nov 14, 2008 By Joel Campbell What's missing from most of the news reporting about the Proposition 8 backlash is equal time and space to the value of a spiritual ... Today in the Bloggernacle Mormon Times all 778 news articles

Addiction treatment specialist Chicago Tribune, United States - Nov 17, 2008 "What I think is so important is that Marty was a very spiritual person and that he always incorporated the concept of spirituality in not only the recovery ...